Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 1509.07504v1

The study by Philip J. Carter, Zoë M. Leinhardt, Tim Elliott, Michael J. Walter, and Sarah T. Stewart delves into the compositional evolution during rocky protoplanet accretion, focusing on the Earth's non-chondritic abundances of refractory lithophile elements. This discrepancy challenges our understanding of the Earth's formation and evolution, leading to the hypothesis that collisional erosion of differentiated planetesimals could explain this non-chondritic composition. To investigate this further, the researchers conducted N-body simulations of terrestrial planet formation to track the growth of planetary embryos from planetesimals. These simulations followed the evolution through runaway and oligarchic growth phases under the Grand Tack model in the absence of giant planets. A state-of-the-art collision model was employed in these simulations to account for multiple collision outcomes such as accretion, erosion, and bouncing events. The results of the simulations revealed that during this intermediate stage of planet formation, embryos exhibited a range of core mass fractions. With significant dynamical excitation, enough mantle could be stripped from growing embryos to match the Earth's non-chondritic Fe/Mg ratio. Additionally, a diverse composition of remnant planetesimals was observed, with collisions producing both iron-rich and silicate-rich fragments. This comprehensive study sheds light on how collisional processes during rocky protoplanet accretion can influence the compositional evolution of terrestrial planets like Earth. The findings provide valuable insights into addressing the discrepancies in elemental abundances and offer a new perspective on understanding planetary formation and evolution processes in our solar system.

• - Study focuses on compositional evolution during rocky protoplanet accretion
• - Earth's non-chondritic abundances of refractory lithophile elements challenge understanding of formation and evolution
• - Hypothesis: Collisional erosion of differentiated planetesimals explains non-chondritic composition
• - Researchers conducted N-body simulations to track growth of planetary embryos from planetesimals under Grand Tack model
• - State-of-the-art collision model used in simulations to account for multiple outcomes like accretion, erosion, bouncing events
• - Results show embryos exhibited range of core mass fractions with enough mantle stripping to match Earth's Fe/Mg ratio
• - Diverse composition of remnant planetesimals observed, producing iron-rich and silicate-rich fragments through collisions
• - Findings shed light on how collisional processes influence compositional evolution of terrestrial planets like Earth

Summary- Scientists studied how rocks came together to form planets. - Earth's different amounts of certain elements make it hard to understand how it was made. - They think that crashing rocks might explain why Earth has these unusual elements. - The researchers used computer simulations to see how planets grew from smaller rocks. - By looking at the results, they learned more about how planets like Earth were formed. Definitions- Compositional evolution: The changes in the makeup of something over time. - Protoplanet: A large body of matter in space that is forming into a planet. - Abundances: How much of something there is. - Refractory lithophile elements: Elements that resist melting and are attracted to rock-forming minerals. - Hypothesis: An idea or explanation that needs to be tested and proven true or false.

Title: Collisional Erosion and the Compositional Evolution of Terrestrial Planets Introduction: The formation and evolution of terrestrial planets, like Earth, have been a topic of interest for scientists for decades. However, recent studies have revealed a discrepancy in the elemental abundances between Earth and chondritic meteorites – the most primitive materials in our solar system. This has led to the hypothesis that collisional erosion during rocky protoplanet accretion could explain this non-chondritic composition. In this blog post, we will delve into a study by Philip J. Carter et al., which explores this idea further. Background: The traditional model of planet formation involves the growth of planetary embryos from smaller bodies called planetesimals through collisions and gravitational interactions. These embryos then continue to grow through runaway and oligarchic growth phases until they reach their final size. However, this model fails to explain the observed non-chondritic composition of Earth's refractory lithophile elements (elements with high melting points). This is because these elements are expected to be evenly distributed throughout the solar system due to their high volatility. Methodology: To investigate how collisional processes during rocky protoplanet accretion could affect compositional evolution, Carter et al. conducted N-body simulations using state-of-the-art collision models. These simulations followed the growth of planetary embryos from planetesimals under the Grand Tack model – a scenario where Jupiter migrates inward towards Mars before moving back outwards again – without considering giant planets' influence. Results: The results of these simulations revealed that during intermediate stages of planet formation, embryos exhibited a range of core mass fractions due to significant dynamical excitation caused by collisions with other growing bodies. This dynamical excitation was found to be crucial in stripping enough mantle material from growing embryos to match Earth's non-chondritic Fe/Mg ratio. Furthermore, these collisions also produced diverse compositions of remnant planetesimals, with some being iron-rich and others silicate-rich. This finding suggests that the composition of Earth's building blocks was not uniform, leading to the observed non-chondritic abundances. Implications: This study provides valuable insights into how collisional processes during rocky protoplanet accretion can influence the compositional evolution of terrestrial planets like Earth. It also offers a new perspective on understanding planetary formation and evolution processes in our solar system. Conclusion: In conclusion, Carter et al.'s study sheds light on the role of collisional erosion in shaping the composition of terrestrial planets during their formation. The results highlight the importance of considering dynamical excitation and diverse compositions of building blocks when studying planetary accretion processes. Further research in this area could help us better understand the complexities involved in forming and evolving terrestrial planets like Earth.