This review highlights the crucial role of mathematical modelling in understanding complex biological systems, specifically focusing on two centre-finding patterning systems in E. coli: midcell division positioning by the MinCDE system and DNA partitioning by the ParABS system. The authors emphasize that despite extensive experimental efforts, these systems were too intricate to unravel solely through experiments and required the injection of quantitative, mathematical thinking. The authors acknowledge that mathematical approaches are still under-represented in the biology literature, particularly within microbiology. They argue that this is unfortunate because prokaryotes offer a comparative simplicity that makes them ideal targets for combined modelling and experimental studies. To assess the current degree of "market penetration" of modelling within microbiology, the authors conducted literature searches from 2002 to 2017. They found that while there has been an increase in the proportion of published papers involving modelling, it remains relatively low at around 1-3% in recent years. Interestingly, when examining high impact journals focused on fundamental microbiology such as Molecular Microbiology and Journal of Bacteriology, there was a higher proportion of papers involving theoretical components compared to general journals like PNAS. However, even in these specialized journals, less than 10% of papers included theoretical content. The authors conclude that progress in microbiology (and biology in general) is being hindered by a lack of theoretical thinking. In conclusion, this review emphasizes the essential role played by mathematical modelling in understanding complex biological systems. While there has been some increase in the utilization of modelling approaches within microbiology, it remains significantly under-utilized. The authors argue for a higher proportion of combined modelling and experimental studies to accelerate scientific progress and overcome obstacles posed by complexity in biological questions.
- - Mathematical modelling plays a crucial role in understanding complex biological systems
- - Two specific patterning systems in E. coli are discussed: midcell division positioning and DNA partitioning
- - Experimental efforts alone were insufficient to unravel these intricate systems, requiring quantitative, mathematical thinking
- - Mathematical approaches are under-represented in biology literature, particularly in microbiology
- - Prokaryotes offer simplicity ideal for combined modelling and experimental studies
- - Literature searches from 2002 to 2017 show low proportion (1-3%) of published papers involving modelling in recent years
- - High impact journals focused on microbiology have a higher proportion of papers involving theoretical components compared to general journals
- - Even specialized journals have less than 10% of papers including theoretical content
- - Lack of theoretical thinking hinders progress in microbiology and biology overall
- - Emphasis on the essential role of mathematical modelling in understanding complex biological systems
- - Call for increased utilization of combined modelling and experimental studies to overcome complexity obstacles and accelerate scientific progress
Mathematical modelling is using math to understand complicated biological systems. E. coli is a type of bacteria that has two specific patterns: where it divides and how its DNA is separated. Scientists needed math to fully understand these patterns because experiments alone weren't enough. Not many biology papers use math, especially in microbiology. Prokaryotes are simple organisms that are good for combining math and experiments. There aren't many papers that use math in microbiology, even in specialized journals. Without using math, progress in biology is slowed down. We need to use both math and experiments together to make scientific progress faster."
Definitions- Mathematical modelling: Using math to understand something complicated.
- E. coli: A type of bacteria.
- DNA: The genetic material inside living things.
- Microbiology: The study of small living things like bacteria.
- Prokaryotes: Simple organisms without a nucleus or other complex structures.
- Journals: Magazines where scientists publish their research.
- Progress: Moving forward or getting better at something.
- Combined modelling and experimental studies: Using both math and experiments together to learn about something
The Role of Mathematical Modelling in Understanding Complex Biological Systems
In recent years, mathematical modelling has become an increasingly important tool for understanding complex biological systems. This review paper focuses on two centre-finding patterning systems in E. coli: midcell division positioning by the MinCDE system and DNA partitioning by the ParABS system. The authors emphasize that despite extensive experimental efforts, these systems were too intricate to unravel solely through experiments and required the injection of quantitative, mathematical thinking.
Underutilization of Mathematical Approaches in Microbiology
The authors acknowledge that mathematical approaches are still under-represented in the biology literature, particularly within microbiology. They argue that this is unfortunate because prokaryotes offer a comparative simplicity that makes them ideal targets for combined modelling and experimental studies. To assess the current degree of "market penetration" of modelling within microbiology, the authors conducted literature searches from 2002 to 2017. They found that while there has been an increase in the proportion of published papers involving modelling, it remains relatively low at around 1-3% in recent years.
Higher Proportion of Theoretical Content In Specialized Journals
Interestingly, when examining high impact journals focused on fundamental microbiology such as Molecular Microbiology and Journal of Bacteriology, there was a higher proportion of papers involving theoretical components compared to general journals like PNAS. However, even in these specialized journals, less than 10% of papers included theoretical content.
Conclusion
The authors conclude that progress in microbiology (and biology in general) is being hindered by a lack of theoretical thinking. In conclusion, this review emphasizes the essential role played by mathematical modelling in understanding complex biological systems. While there has been some increase in the utilization of modelling approaches within microbiology, it remains significantly under-utilized. The authors argue for a higher proportion of combined modelling and experimental studies to accelerate scientific progress and overcome obstacles posed by complexity in biological questions