In this comprehensive review, Md. Nasimul Islam Maruf and colleagues delve into the classification, potential role, and mathematical modeling of power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies in energy systems. The authors highlight the maturity of these technologies and their significant impact on the European energy transition. Despite their importance, the complexity of detailed models poses challenges for integration into large-scale energy models that prioritize simplicity and computational efficiency. The paper addresses a critical gap in existing literature by identifying and categorizing major power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies that are climate-neutral, efficient, and technologically matured to replace fossil fuel-based heating systems. Through a thorough analysis, electric heat pumps, boilers, resistance heaters, and hybrid heating systems emerge as promising options for transitioning to sustainable heating solutions. Furthermore, the authors discuss the technology readiness levels (TRL) of these identified technologies, providing insights into their current status ranging from basic principles observed to actual system completion and qualification through test demonstrations. By presenting mathematical modeling equations for these technologies in large-scale optimization energy models, the paper offers a valuable resource for researchers and policymakers seeking to incorporate these innovative solutions into sustainable energy systems. Acknowledging the contributions of Prof. Dr. Olav Hohmeyer towards shaping this research work, the authors declare no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could influence their findings. Supplementary data related to this study can be accessed online for further exploration. Overall, this review serves as a comprehensive guide for understanding the potential roles of power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies in advancing a sustainable European energy system. With a focus on technological advancements and practical applications, this research contributes significantly to shaping future strategies for achieving climate-neutral heating solutions across various sectors.
- - Md. Nasimul Islam Maruf and colleagues review power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies in energy systems
- - Highlight the maturity and significant impact of these technologies on the European energy transition
- - Complexity of detailed models poses challenges for integration into large-scale energy models
- - Identifying major climate-neutral, efficient, and technologically matured power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies to replace fossil fuel-based heating systems
- - Electric heat pumps, boilers, resistance heaters, and hybrid heating systems are promising options for sustainable heating solutions
- - Discuss technology readiness levels (TRL) of identified technologies
- - Offer mathematical modeling equations for these technologies in large-scale optimization energy models
- - Acknowledge Prof. Dr. Olav Hohmeyer's contributions towards shaping the research work
- - Declare no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could influence findings
- - Serve as a comprehensive guide for understanding the potential roles of these technologies in advancing a sustainable European energy system
SummaryResearchers reviewed technologies that can convert power into heat and store thermal energy. These technologies are well-developed and have a big impact on changing how Europe gets its energy. Making detailed models of these technologies is hard because they are so complex. People are looking for ways to use clean and advanced heating systems instead of ones that rely on fossil fuels. Some good options include electric heat pumps, boilers, resistance heaters, and hybrid heating systems.
Definitions- Power-to-heat: Technology that converts electrical power into heat energy.
- Thermal energy storage: Storing heat in a way that it can be used later.
- Maturity: How developed or advanced something is.
- Integration: Combining different things together smoothly.
- Sustainable: Something that can continue for a long time without causing harm to the environment.
Introduction
The transition to sustainable energy systems has become a global priority in recent years due to the increasing concerns over climate change and the depletion of fossil fuel resources. In Europe, heating accounts for approximately 50% of total energy consumption, making it a crucial sector for decarbonization efforts. As such, there is a growing need for alternative heating solutions that are climate-neutral, efficient, and technologically matured.
In this comprehensive review paper, Md. Nasimul Islam Maruf and colleagues delve into the classification, potential role, and mathematical modeling of power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies in energy systems. The authors highlight the maturity of these technologies and their significant impact on the European energy transition.
Overview of Power-to-Heat and Thermal Energy Storage Technologies
Power-to-heat technologies refer to processes that convert electrical or renewable power into heat through various methods such as electric resistance heaters or heat pumps. On the other hand, thermal energy storage involves storing excess heat generated from power production or other sources for later use.
The paper identifies four major categories of power-to-heat technologies: electric heat pumps (EHPs), boilers, resistance heaters (RHs), and hybrid heating systems (HHS). These technologies have been extensively studied in previous research but have not yet been fully integrated into large-scale energy models due to their complexity.
Electric Heat Pumps (EHPs)
EHPs use electricity to transfer heat from one location to another using refrigerants or water as a medium. They can provide both space heating and cooling functions with high efficiency compared to traditional heating systems.
Boilers
Boilers are commonly used in residential buildings for space heating by burning natural gas or oil. However, advancements in technology have led to more efficient boiler designs that can also utilize renewable fuels such as biomass or hydrogen.
Resistance Heaters (RHs)
RHs are the most straightforward form of power-to-heat technology, where electrical resistance is used to generate heat. They are commonly used in electric water heaters and space heating systems.
Hybrid Heating Systems (HHS)
HHS combines two or more heating technologies, such as a boiler and an EHP, to optimize energy efficiency and reduce carbon emissions. These systems can switch between different heat sources depending on their availability and cost-effectiveness.
The paper also discusses various thermal energy storage technologies, including sensible heat storage, latent heat storage, thermochemical storage, and cryogenic energy storage. These technologies allow excess heat to be stored for later use when there is a high demand for heating.
Technology Readiness Levels (TRL) of Power-to-Heat and Thermal Energy Storage Technologies
To assess the maturity of these technologies, the authors use Technology Readiness Levels (TRL), which range from 1-9 based on their level of development. The TRL scale starts at basic principles observed (TRL 1) to actual system completion and qualification through test demonstrations (TRL 9).
Through a thorough analysis of existing literature, the paper identifies EHPs as the most mature technology with a TRL of 8-9 due to its widespread commercialization in Europe. Boilers have a TRL of 7-8 while RHs have a lower TRL ranging from 4-6 due to their limited application in large-scale heating systems. HHS has not yet been fully developed but shows great potential with ongoing research projects across Europe.
In terms of thermal energy storage technologies, sensible heat storage has the highest TRL at 8 due to its extensive use in district heating systems. Latent heat storage has a slightly lower TRL at 6-7 while thermochemical and cryogenic energy storage technologies are still in the early stages of development with TRLs ranging from 2-4.
Mathematical Modeling for Large-Scale Energy Optimization Models
One of the main challenges in integrating power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies into large-scale energy models is their complexity. These detailed models require significant computational resources, making them less practical for use in real-time decision-making processes.
To address this issue, the paper presents mathematical modeling equations for each technology that can be incorporated into large-scale optimization energy models. By simplifying these complex systems, researchers and policymakers can better understand their potential impact on sustainable energy systems and make informed decisions.
Contributions and Implications
This review paper addresses a critical gap in existing literature by providing a comprehensive overview of power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies. It identifies promising options for transitioning to sustainable heating solutions while also assessing their maturity levels through TRLs.
The authors also acknowledge the contributions of Prof. Dr. Olav Hohmeyer towards shaping this research work, highlighting the collaborative effort involved in advancing sustainable energy solutions. Furthermore, they declare no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could influence their findings, ensuring unbiased results.
Supplementary data related to this study can be accessed online for further exploration, providing additional resources for researchers and policymakers interested in incorporating these innovative solutions into sustainable energy systems.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this comprehensive review serves as a valuable resource for understanding the potential roles of power-to-heat and thermal energy storage technologies in advancing a sustainable European energy system. With a focus on technological advancements and practical applications, this research contributes significantly to shaping future strategies for achieving climate-neutral heating solutions across various sectors. As these technologies continue to mature and become more widely adopted, they have the potential to play a crucial role in reducing carbon emissions and promoting a greener, more sustainable future.