This paper introduces the Transparency Index framework, which aims to develop transparent AI systems for real-world educational scenarios. While numerous AI ethics checklists and frameworks have been proposed focusing on different dimensions of ethical AI such as fairness, explainability, and safety, no such work has been done on developing transparent AI systems for education. The Transparency Index framework was iteratively co-designed with different stakeholders of AI in education, including educators, ed-tech experts, and AI practitioners. The framework maps the requirements of transparency for different categories of stakeholders of AI in education and demonstrates that transparency considerations are embedded in the entire AI development process from the data collection stage until the AI system is deployed in the real world and iteratively improved. The authors highlight how transparency enables the implementation of other ethical dimensions in education like interpretability, accountability, and safety. For instance, it's important to document thoroughly the data that an AI system is trained on because this training data plays a significant role in determining how an AI system would work expectedly. The Transparency Index framework provides different aspects of the data processing stage that AI practitioners need to document. Additionally, details of models used for decision-making can be documented and shared publicly by ed-tech companies developing AI-powered products to enable reproducible research. While some researchers have argued against complete transparency like making code public due to concerns about hindering innovation or sharing trade secrets that provide a competitive edge over others, all three stakeholders found transparency through the Transparency Index framework useful. Educators as users of these products believed transparency helped them understand their products better while developers and providers believed it made them accountable for their work. The authors created this framework based on popular frameworks for documentation, robustness, and reproducibility identified during a literature review across three stages: data processing stage; machine learning modelling stage; deployment and iterative improvements stage. They then applied these frameworks during the development of an educational tool using domain-agnostic frameworks for educational settings to identify gaps. The authors conclude by discussing the importance of transparency in developing AI-powered educational technologies and proposing an index framework for its conceptualization for AI in education.
- - The Transparency Index framework aims to develop transparent AI systems for real-world educational scenarios.
- - No previous work has been done on developing transparent AI systems for education.
- - The framework was co-designed with different stakeholders of AI in education, including educators, ed-tech experts, and AI practitioners.
- - Transparency considerations are embedded in the entire AI development process from the data collection stage until the AI system is deployed in the real world and iteratively improved.
- - Transparency enables implementation of other ethical dimensions in education like interpretability, accountability, and safety.
- - The framework provides different aspects of the data processing stage that AI practitioners need to document and details of models used for decision-making can be documented and shared publicly by ed-tech companies developing AI-powered products to enable reproducible research.
- - All three stakeholders found transparency through the Transparency Index framework useful.
- - The authors created this framework based on popular frameworks for documentation, robustness, and reproducibility identified during a literature review across three stages: data processing stage; machine learning modelling stage; deployment and iterative improvements stage.
- - The authors conclude by discussing the importance of transparency in developing AI-powered educational technologies and proposing an index framework for its conceptualization for AI in education.
The Transparency Index framework is a way to make sure that AI systems used in schools are open and honest. This means that everyone can understand how they work and why they make certain decisions. No one has done this before, so it's new and exciting! The people who made the framework talked to lots of different experts to make sure it was good for everyone. Being transparent helps us know if the AI system is doing what it's supposed to do and keeps us safe. It also makes sure that we can trust the AI system and ask questions if we need to.
Understanding the Need for Transparency in AI-Powered Educational Technologies
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly being used to develop educational technologies that can help improve learning outcomes. However, there are ethical considerations when it comes to developing and deploying these AI-powered products. One of the most important ethical dimensions is transparency, which has been overlooked in existing frameworks for ethical AI. To address this gap, a research paper recently published by researchers from the University of Cambridge introduces a new framework called the Transparency Index Framework (TIF). This framework aims to provide guidance on how to develop transparent AI systems for real-world educational scenarios.
What Is Transparency?
Transparency refers to making information about an AI system available so that users and developers can understand how it works and why certain decisions are made. It also involves documenting data processing stages, machine learning models used for decision-making, and any changes made during deployment or iterative improvements. By providing transparency into an AI system’s development process, users can better understand its functioning and trust its decisions more easily while developers become accountable for their work.
Why Is Transparency Important For Developing Ethical AI Systems?
Transparency is essential for ensuring other ethical dimensions such as fairness, explainability, safety, interpretability, accountability etc., in education settings where AI systems are deployed. For instance, if an AI system is trained on biased data then it will produce biased results even if all other aspects of its design are fair or safe. Thus understanding what data was used to train an AI system becomes important before deploying it in real world scenarios as this training data plays a significant role in determining how anAI system would work expectedly. Additionally details of models used for decision-making should be documented and shared publicly by ed-tech companies developing these products so that reproducible research can be enabled .
The Transparency Index Framework:
The TIF was co-designed with different stakeholders including educators , ed - tech experts ,and practitioners through multiple iterations . The framework maps out requirements of transparency across three stages : data processing stage ; machine learning modelling stage ; deployment & iterative improvement stage . Popular frameworks were identified during literature review across these stages which were then applied during development of educational tool using domain agnostic frameworks suitable for educational settings . These included documentation , robustness & reproducibility frameworks . While some researchers have argued against complete transparency like making code public due to concerns about hindering innovation or sharing trade secrets that provide competitive edge over others , all three stakeholders found usefulness through TIF . Educators as users believed transparency helped them understand product better while developers & providers believed it made them accountable for their work .
Conclusion:
The authors conclude by discussing importance of transparency in developing AIPowered educational technologies & proposing index framework conceptualizing same specifically tailored towards needs of education sector . They believe that such efforts will enable implementation of other ethical dimensions like interpretability , accountability & safety thus helping create trustworthy & responsible use cases around Artificial Intelligence powered tools within education sector