Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2303.13861v1

In 2017, the first interstellar object observed in our solar system, 1I/`Oumuamua, exhibited several peculiar properties, including extreme elongation and non-gravitational acceleration. A recent study by Bergner and Seligman (2023) proposed that evaporation of trapped H$_2$ created by cosmic rays (CRs) can explain the non-gravitational acceleration. However, a new study by Thiem Hoang and Abraham Loeb has shown that Bergner and Seligman's calculation of surface temperature ignored the crucial cooling effect of evaporating H$_2$. By taking into account the cooling by H$_2$ evaporation, they found that the surface temperature of H$_2$-water ice is lower than the temperature obtained by Bergner and Seligman (2023) by a factor of 9. This means that the thermal speed of outgassing H$_2$ is decreased by a factor of 3. As a result, all H$_2$ from water ice would need to be dissociated by CRs in the interstellar medium, making Bergner and Seligman's model untenable as an explanation for the properties of 1I/`Oumuamua. Hoang and Loeb also found that the lower surface temperature influences the thermal annealing of water ice which is a key process appealed to by Bergner and Seligman (2023). The lower surface temperature means that less energy is available for thermal annealing to occur. Therefore their results suggest that alternative explanations are needed for the peculiar properties observed in 1I/`Oumuamua. This study highlights how important it is to consider all relevant physical processes when developing models to explain astronomical observations. It also demonstrates how scientific knowledge can evolve through ongoing research and refinement.

• - In 2017, the first interstellar object observed in our solar system, 1I/`Oumuamua, exhibited several peculiar properties.
• - A recent study by Bergner and Seligman (2023) proposed that evaporation of trapped H$_2$ created by cosmic rays (CRs) can explain the non-gravitational acceleration.
• - However, a new study by Thiem Hoang and Abraham Loeb has shown that Bergner and Seligman's calculation of surface temperature ignored the crucial cooling effect of evaporating H$_2$.
• - By taking into account the cooling by H$_2$ evaporation, they found that the surface temperature of H$_2$-water ice is lower than the temperature obtained by Bergner and Seligman (2023) by a factor of 9.
• - This means that the thermal speed of outgassing H$_2$ is decreased by a factor of 3. As a result, all H$_2$ from water ice would need to be dissociated by CRs in the interstellar medium, making Bergner and Seligman's model untenable as an explanation for the properties of 1I/`Oumuamua.
• - Hoang and Loeb also found that the lower surface temperature influences the thermal annealing of water ice which is a key process appealed to by Bergner and Seligman (2023).
• - The lower surface temperature means that less energy is available for thermal annealing to occur. Therefore their results suggest that alternative explanations are needed for the peculiar properties observed in 1I/`Oumuamua.
• - This study highlights how important it is to consider all relevant physical processes when developing models to explain astronomical observations.
• - It also demonstrates how scientific knowledge can evolve through ongoing research and refinement.
• Bullet points:
• - First interstellar object observed in our solar system, 1I/`Oumuamua, exhibited peculiar properties
• - Bergner and Seligman (2023) proposed evaporation of trapped H$_2$ created by cosmic rays can explain non-gravitational acceleration
• - Hoang and Loeb found Bergner and Seligman's calculation of surface temperature ignored crucial cooling effect of evaporating H$_2$
• - Surface temperature of H$_2$-water ice is lower than temperature obtained by Bergner and Seligman (2023) by a factor of 9
• - Thermal

In 2017, scientists saw a strange object in our solar system called 1I/`Oumuamua. Some researchers thought that cosmic rays could explain why it moved strangely. But other scientists found a mistake in their calculations about how hot the object was. They discovered that the object was actually much cooler than they thought, which means it couldn't have been caused by cosmic rays like they originally thought. This shows how important it is to check all the details when trying to understand something new in space. Definitions- Interstellar: relating to or located between stars - Cosmic rays: high-energy particles that come from space - Evaporation: when a liquid turns into a gas - Temperature: how hot or cold something is - Annealing: a process of heating and cooling materials to make them stronger or more durable

Exploring the Properties of 1I/`Oumuamua: A New Study by Thiem Hoang and Abraham Loeb

In 2017, astronomers were surprised to observe an interstellar object in our solar system for the first time. This mysterious object, named 1I/`Oumuamua, exhibited several peculiar properties that had never been seen before. One such property was its non-gravitational acceleration which could not be explained by traditional models. In a recent study published in 2023, Bergner and Seligman proposed that evaporation of trapped H$_2$ created by cosmic rays (CRs) could explain this phenomenon. However, a new study conducted by Thiem Hoang and Abraham Loeb has shown that their model may not be viable after all.

The Role of Surface Temperature

Bergner and Seligman's calculation of surface temperature ignored the crucial cooling effect of evaporating H$_2$. By taking into account this factor, Hoang and Loeb found that the surface temperature is lower than what was previously calculated by a factor of 9. This means that the thermal speed of outgassing H$_2$ is decreased by a factor of 3. As a result, all H$_2$ from water ice would need to be dissociated by CRs in the interstellar medium for Bergner and Seligman's model to hold true – something which is highly unlikely given current understanding about cosmic rays in space.

Implications on Thermal Annealing Processes

The lower surface temperature also influences another key process appealed to by Bergner and Seligman (2023): thermal annealing of water ice. Since less energy is available at lower temperatures, thermal annealing will occur much more slowly than predicted under their original assumptions – making it difficult for their model to explain certain properties observed in 1I/`Oumuamua as well as other similar objects discovered since then.

Conclusion

This study highlights how important it is to consider all relevant physical processes when developing models to explain astronomical observations – something which can only be achieved through ongoing research and refinement over time. The results obtained from Hoang and Loeb's work suggest that alternative explanations are needed for the peculiar properties observed in 1I/`Oumuamua as well as other similar objects discovered since then; further research will be necessary if we hope to gain deeper insight into these phenomena going forward.