Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2305.01308v1

Historians have fiercely objected to the trend of diagnosing deceased scientists by reconstructing from scant evidence, calling these diagnoses myths. Despite their efforts at demolishing myths, Einstein has been constantly diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome. Private letters found in the Collected Papers of Albert Einstein reveal that he was brilliant, inspirational, abrasive and rebellious - precisely the type of truth-seeker to create a scientific revolution. People have written biographies and books on Einstein’s private life based on this evidence, leading to retrospective diagnoses of all sorts of things. Historians who care about Einstein’s legacy fiercely object to this abuse of his privacy and engage in futile efforts to protect it. However, it turns out that historians are susceptible to biases like any other scholar. Simon Baron-Cohen's diagnosis of Einstein with Asperger's syndrome started this trend of diagnosing deceased scientists based on scant evidence.

• - Historians object to diagnosing deceased scientists based on scant evidence, calling these diagnoses myths
• - Despite this, Einstein has been constantly diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome
• - Private letters found in the Collected Papers of Albert Einstein reveal he was brilliant, inspirational, abrasive and rebellious
• - Biographies and books have been written on Einstein's private life based on this evidence, leading to retrospective diagnoses of all sorts of things
• - Historians fiercely object to this abuse of his privacy and engage in futile efforts to protect it
• - However, historians are susceptible to biases like any other scholar
• - Simon Baron-Cohen's diagnosis of Einstein with Asperger's syndrome started this trend.

1. Historians don't like to say someone had a certain condition if they don't have enough proof. 2. People keep saying Einstein had Asperger's, even though historians don't agree. 3. Letters that were kept private show that Einstein was really smart, but also difficult and rebellious. 4. Some people wrote books about Einstein's personal life using these letters, and said he had different conditions. 5. Historians try to protect Einstein's privacy, but sometimes people still make assumptions about him. 6. One person named Simon Baron-Cohen started the idea that Einstein had Asperger's. Definitions- Historians: people who study and write about history - Diagnose: when a doctor says what illness or condition someone has - Scant evidence: not enough proof or information - Asperger's syndrome: a condition that affects how people communicate and interact with others - Private letters: messages written by someone that were meant only for certain people to see - Biographies: books about someone's life story - Retrospective diagnoses: when doctors try to figure out what illness or condition someone had in the past based on information they have now - Fiercely object: strongly disagree or protest against something - Engage in futile efforts: try really hard to do something, but it doesn't work out in the end - Biases: when someone has an unfair preference towards one thing over another

The Controversy Surrounding Retrospective Diagnoses of Albert Einstein

Albert Einstein is one of the most famous scientists in history, and his legacy has been subject to much debate. While some historians have fiercely objected to the trend of diagnosing deceased scientists by reconstructing from scant evidence, calling these diagnoses myths, others have argued that it can be a useful tool for understanding their lives and work. This controversy was sparked when Simon Baron-Cohen diagnosed Einstein with Asperger's syndrome based on limited evidence.

Einstein’s Private Life

Private letters found in the Collected Papers of Albert Einstein reveal that he was brilliant, inspirational, abrasive and rebellious - precisely the type of truth-seeker to create a scientific revolution. People have written biographies and books on Einstein’s private life based on this evidence, leading to retrospective diagnoses of all sorts of things. Historians who care about Einstein’s legacy fiercely object to this abuse of his privacy and engage in futile efforts to protect it.

Historians Susceptible To Bias

However, it turns out that historians are susceptible to biases like any other scholar. Simon Baron-Cohen's diagnosis of Einstein with Asperger's syndrome started this trend of diagnosing deceased scientists based on scant evidence. This led many people to question whether or not retrospective diagnoses should be allowed at all given the potential for bias and inaccuracy due to lack of information available about a person after they die.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while retrospective diagnoses may offer insight into a deceased scientist’s life and work, there is also potential for bias due to lack of information available after death as well as potential misuse or misinterpretation by those making such diagnoses without proper training or expertise in doing so. For these reasons, historians must take great care when engaging in such activities so as not to tarnish someone’s legacy through inaccurate or biased interpretations which could lead people astray rather than providing accurate insight into their lives and works.