Importance of stable mass transfer and stellar winds for the formation of gravitational wave sources

Abstract: The large number of gravitational wave (GW) detections have revealed the properties of the merging black hole binary population, but their formation is still heavily debated. Understanding the imprint of stellar physics on the observable GW population will shed light on how we can use the gravitational wave data, along with other observations, to constrain the poorly understood evolution of massive binaries. We perform a parameter study for the classical isolated binary formation channel in order to better understand how sensitive the properties of the coalescing binary black hole population are on uncertainties related of stable mass transfer phase and stellar winds. We use the population synthesis code SeBa to simulate the evolution of massive binaries on a large range of metallicities. We vary five assumptions: 1 and 2) the mass transfer efficiency and the angular momentum loss during the first mass transfer phase, 3) the mass transfer stability criteria for giant donors with radiative envelopes, 4) the effective temperature at which an evolved star develops a deep convective envelope, and 5) the stellar winds. Our varied parameters have a complex, interrelated effects on the population properties of GW sources. Most notably, the impact of the mass transfer stability criteria parameter depends on the assumed mass transfer efficiency. The uncertainties in the assumed angular momentum loss have significant effects on the relative rates of the two dominant channels. Because of the numerous uncertainties and lack of reliable models direct inference of massive binary physics from gravitational data is not recommended.