Galactic Archaeology with [Mg/Mn] versus [Al/Fe] abundance ratios -- Uncertainties and caveats
Authors: Arianna Vasini, Emanuele Spitoni, Francesca Matteucci
Abstract
The diagram depicting the abundance ratios [Mg/Mn] vs. [Al/Fe] has gained attention in recent literature as a valuable tool for exploring fundamental aspects of the evolution of the Milky Way and the Local Group. In particular, this combination of elements is supposed to be highly sensitive to the star formation history (SFH), unveiled by the imprints left on those abundances. Unfortunately, a complete discussion on the uncertainties associated is still missing, making it difficult to know how reliable the associated results are. In this paper we analyze, by means of detailed chemical evolution models, the nuclear uncertainties of Mg, Al, Mn and Fe to show how different yields can affect the trends in the [Mg/Mn] vs. [Al/Fe] plane. In fact, if different yield assumptions produce conflicting results, then the [Mg/Mn] vs. [Al/Fe] diagram does not represent a strong diagnostic for the SFH of a galaxy. We discuss the results on the [Mg/Mn] vs. [Al/Fe] diagram, as predicted by several Milky Way (MW) and Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) chemical evolution models adopting different nucleosynthesis prescriptions. The results show that the literature yields require some corrective factors to reproduce the APOGEE DR17 abundances of Mg, Al and Mn in the MW and that the same factors can also improve the results for the LMC. In particular, we show that by modifying the massive stars yields of Mg and Al the behaviour of the [Mg/Mn] vs. [Al/Fe] plot changes substantially. In conclusion, by changing the yields within their error bars, one obtains trends which differ strongly, making it difficult to draw any reliable conclusion on the SFH of galaxies. The proposed diagram is therefore uncertain from a theoretical point of view and it could represent a good diagnostic for SFH if the uncertainties on the nucleosynthesis of these elements (Mg, Mn, Al and Fe) could be reduced by future stellar calculations.
The papers around it, by date and closeness
Higher is closer to this paper; left is older. Lines join papers close to each other: groups of lines are sub-topics. Select a point to see why it is there. Back to the summary of this paper
Papers around this one
Ranked by how close their title and abstract are to this paper’s. Select some to read them together.
Closest papers
-
Many elements matter: Detailed abundance patterns reveal star-formation and enrichment differences among Milky Way structural componentsEmily J. Griffith, David W. Hogg, Sten Hasselquist et al. · 2024 · Astrophysics of Galaxies · cited 9 times · AI summary available
Abstract
Many nucleosynthetic channels create the elements, but two-parameter models characterized by $\alpha$ and Fe nonetheless predict stellar abundances in the Galactic disk to accuracies of 0.02 to 0.05 dex for most measured elements, near the level of current abundance uncertainties. It is difficult to make individual measurements more precise than this to investigate lower-amplitude nucleosynthetic effects, but population studies of mean abundance patterns can reveal more subtle abundance differences. Here we look at the detailed abundances for 67315 stars from APOGEE DR17, but in the form of abundance residuals away from a best-fit two-parameter, data-driven nucleosynthetic model. We find tha…
-
Chemical Cartography with APOGEE: Mapping Disk Populations with a Two-Process Model and Residual AbundancesDavid H. Weinberg, Jon A. Holtzman, Jennifer A. Johnson et al. · 2021 · Astrophysics of Galaxies · cited 28 times · AI summary available
Abstract
We apply a novel statistical analysis to measurements of 16 elemental abundances in 34,410 Milky Way disk stars from the final data release (DR17) of APOGEE-2. Building on recent work, we fit median abundance ratio trends [X/Mg] vs. [Mg/H] with a 2-process model, which decomposes abundance patterns into a "prompt" component tracing core collapse supernovae and a "delayed" component tracing Type Ia supernovae. For each sample star, we fit the amplitudes of these two components, then compute the residuals \Delta[X/H] from this two-parameter fit. The rms residuals range from ~0.01-0.03 dex for the most precisely measured APOGEE abundances to ~0.1 dex for Na, V, and Ce. The correlations of resid…
-
Inhomogeneous Galactic Chemical Evolution: Modelling Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxies of the Large Magellanic CloudRyan K. Alexander, Fiorenzo Vincenzo, Alexander P. Ji et al. · 2023 · Astrophysics of Galaxies · cited 10 times · AI summary available
Abstract
Ultra-faint dwarf galaxies are among the oldest and most metal-poor galaxies in the cosmos, observed to contain no traces of gas at the present time and a high dark matter mass fraction. Understanding the chemical abundance dispersion in such extreme environments could shed light on the properties of the first generations of stars in the cosmos. We present a novel inhomogeneous chemical evolution model, i-GEtool, that we apply to two ultra-faint dwarf galaxies, Carina II (Car II) and Reticulum II (Ret II), which are satellites of the Large Magellanic Cloud. In summary, our model is based on the Monte Carlo sampling of the initial mass function as star formation proceeds in different gas cell…
-
Testing Chemical Tagging with LAMOST: Intrinsic Abundance Dispersion of Subgiant Stars in the Galactic DiskYa-Qian Wu, Mao-Sheng Xiang, Gang Zhao et al. · 2026 · Monthly notices of the Royal Astronomical Society · Not summarized yet
Abstract
The scatter in elemental abundances among stars of similar age and metallicity reflects chemical inhomogeneity in their birth environments, making abundance scatter a key observable for chemical-tagging studies of Galactic formation and evolution. Using a large sample of subgiant stars with precise ages and elemental abundances derived from LAMOST low-resolution spectra, we investigate the intrinsic chemical abundance scatter of the low-α thin disk near the solar neighborhood (7 < R < 10 kpc). We model the abundance ratio [X/Fe], for each of the 19 elements of concern, as a function of age, [Fe/H], and [Mg/Fe], and deduce the intrinsic dispersions with a forward modelling technique. Our resu…
-
Lithium, masses, and kinematics of young Galactic dwarf and giant stars with extreme [α/Fe] ratiosS. Borisov, N. Prantzos, C. Charbonnel · 2022 · Solar and Stellar Astrophysics · cited 4 times · AI summary available
Abstract
Recent spectroscopic explorations of large Galactic stellar samples stars have revealed the existence of red giants with [{\alpha}/Fe] ratios anomalously high given their relatively young ages. We revisit the GALAH DR3 survey to look for both dwarf and giant stars with extreme [{\alpha}/Fe] ratios, i.e., upper 1% in the [{\alpha}/Fe]-[Fe/H] plane over the range in [Fe/H] between -1.1 and +0.4 dex. We call these outliers ex{\alpha}fe stars. We use the GALAH DR3 data along with their Value-Added Catalogue to trace the properties (chemical abundances, masses, ages, and kinematics) of the ex{\alpha}fe. We investigate the effects of secular stellar evolution and of the magnitude limitations of th…
-
Rediscovering the Milky Way with orbit superposition approach and APOGEE data II. Chrono-chemo-kinematics of the discSergey Khoperskov, Matthias Steinmetz, Misha Haywood et al. · 2024 · Astrophysics of Galaxies · cited 2 times · AI summary available
Abstract
The stellar disc is the dominant luminous component of the Milky Way (MW). Although our understanding of its structure is rapidly expanding due to advances in large-scale stellar surveys, our picture of the MW disc remains substantially obscured by selection functions and incomplete spatial coverage of observational data. In this work, we present the comprehensive chrono-chemo-kinematic structure of the MW disc, recovered using a novel orbit superposition approach combined with data from APOGEE DR 17. We detect periodic azimuthal metallicity variations within 6-8 kpc with an amplitude of 0.05-0.1 dex peaking along the bar major axis. The radial metallicity profile of the MW also varies with …
-
Hint of a bimodal Mg-Al anticorrelation in the metal-poor globular cluster NGC 4372Camila Beltrand, Macarena Uribe, S. Villanova et al. · 2026 · Astronomy & Astrophysics · Not summarized yet
Abstract
We present a detailed chemical abundance analysis of seven red giant branch stars in the very metal-poor globular cluster NGC 4372 based on high-resolution UVES spectra. Our study aims to characterize the chemical evolution of NGC 4372 and investigate the presence of multiple populations. We derived abundances for 17 elements, including light, iron-peak, α, and heavy elements, using both equivalent width and spectral synthesis methods. We find a mean cluster metallicity of Fe/H =-2.36 ± 0.03 dex, with no evidence of an intrinsic iron spread. The cluster exhibits a typical α-enhancement of α/Fe = 0.33 ± 0.05 dex and a well-defined Na-O anticorrelation, confirming that NGC 4372 hosts at least …
-
M giants with IGRINS. III. Abundance trends for 21 elements in the solar neighborhood fromhigh-resolution near-infrared spectraG. Nandakumar, N. Ryde, R. Forsberg et al. · 2024 · Astronomy & Astrophysics · cited 7 times · Not summarized yet
Abstract
To be able to investigate the chemical history of the entire Milky Way, it is imperative to also study its dust-obscured regions in detail, as this is where most of the mass lies. The Galactic Center is an example of such a region. Due to the intervening dust along the line of sight, near-infrared spectroscopic investigations are necessary to study this region of interest. The aim of this work is to demonstrate that M giants observed at high spectral resolution in the H- and K-bands (1.5-2.4\ can yield useful abundance ratio trends versus metallicity for 21 elements. These elements can then also be studied for heavily dust-obscured regions of the Galaxy, such as the Galactic Center. The abun…
Prior work it builds on
-
arXivLucy Rosenbloom · 2019 · Charleston Advisor · cited 16,724 times · Not summarized yet
Abstract
The innovative preprint repository, arXiv, was created in the early 1990s to improve access to scientific research. arXiv contains millions of Open Access articles in physics, mathematics, computer science, quantitative biology, quantitative finance, statistics, electrical engineering and systems science, and economics. All articles are available for free download on the open web. Often research findings are available on arXiv before they are published in a peer-reviewed journal. arXiv relies on a collaborative support business model where institutions that most heavily utilize arXiv contribute financially. Support also comes from Cornell University and the Simons Foundation.
Papers that cite it
-
oMEGACat. X. Shedding Light on the Disrupted Dwarf Galaxy of Omega CentauriStefano O. Souza, N. Neumayer, A. Seth et al. · 2026 · Astrophysical Journal · cited 1 time · Not summarized yet
Abstract
Omega Centauri (ω Cen) is the most massive and chemically complex star cluster in the Milky Way (MW) and is widely interpreted as the surviving nuclear star cluster of an accreted dwarf galaxy, although the identity of its parent remains uncertain. We test whether the merger remnants Sequoia, Thamnos, and Gaia–Enceladus (GE) originated in a single progenitor, the ω Dwarf, whose nucleus survives as ω Cen. Combining APOGEE and GALAH abundances with Gaia astrometry, we reconstruct the progenitor’s chemical structure using orbital energy as a proxy for premerger radius. The chemically evolved, younger, Al–N-rich population is strongly concentrated toward the center, consistent with formation dur…
-
Evidence of a massive accretion event 1.8 billion years before the Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus mergerD. Massari, C. Zerbinati, C. Fanelli et al. · 2026 · Nature Astronomy · cited 2 times · Not summarized yet
Abstract
The merger history of the Galaxy has been traced back firmly to a redshift of 2 (10 billion years ago). While evidence for the existence of at least one more substantial merger before this time has been presented, its interpretation is yet to be fully established. Here we show that the population of globular clusters around the Galaxy depicts three distinct age–metallicity sequences, one associated with the progenitor of the Milky Way, one with the merger with Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus 10 billion years ago and a third intermediate sequence associated with at least one merger that we estimate took place about 1.8 billion years before Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus. This discovery has been possible thank…
Go further
How are these papers found?
We compare the title and abstract of this paper with those of every paper summarized on this site, and with the papers Semantic Scholar recommends, those it cites and those citing it (for a much-cited paper, its most recent citations and, from OpenAlex, the most cited ones). Among the prior work and the follow-ups, the papers that use each other in depth, a method it uses and the much-cited follow-ups come a little higher. The levels (very close, close, related) come from the similarity of the texts, not from a judgment of quality; * marks a paper without an abstract, compared by its title. The sentence under a paper is written by an AI from the two abstracts: check it in the papers. A paper marked not relevant by three readers leaves the list.
Updated on 4 November 2026.