Double Descent in Portfolio Optimization: Dance between Theoretical Sharpe Ratio and Estimation Accuracy

Abstract: We study the relationship between model complexity and out-of-sample performance in the context of mean-variance portfolio optimization. Representing model complexity by the number of assets, we find that the performance of low-dimensional models initially improves with complexity but then declines due to overfitting. As model complexity becomes sufficiently high, the performance improves with complexity again, resulting in a double ascent Sharpe ratio curve similar to the double descent phenomenon observed in artificial intelligence. The underlying mechanisms involve an intricate interaction between the theoretical Sharpe ratio and estimation accuracy. In high-dimensional models, the theoretical Sharpe ratio approaches its upper limit, and the overfitting problem is reduced because there are more parameters than data restrictions, which allows us to choose well-behaved parameters based on inductive bias.