Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2212.14052v3

The paper titled "Hungry Hungry Hippos: Towards Language Modeling with State Space Models" explores the performance of state space models (SSMs) in language modeling compared to attention-based models like Transformers. While SSMs have shown excellent sequence modeling performance in some domains, they underperform attention in language modeling tasks. Additionally, despite their linear scaling in sequence length, SSMs are slower than Transformers due to inefficient hardware utilization. To bridge the gap between SSMs and attention in language modeling, the authors conduct experiments using synthetic language modeling tasks. They identify two key challenges that existing SSMs struggle with: recalling earlier tokens in the sequence and comparing tokens across the sequence. To address these limitations, they propose a new SSM layer called H3, specifically designed for these capabilities. The H3 layer achieves comparable performance to attention on synthetic languages and comes within 0.4 perplexity per token (PPL) of Transformers on OpenWebText dataset. Furthermore, the authors introduce a hybrid model combining a 125M-parameter H3-attention model with two attention layers. Surprisingly, this hybrid model outperforms Transformers by 1.0 PPL on OpenWebText dataset. To improve the efficiency of training SSMs on modern hardware, the authors propose FlashConv. This technique utilizes a fused block Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) algorithm to enhance efficiency for sequences up to 8K length. It also introduces a novel state passing algorithm that leverages the recurrent properties of SSMs to scale to longer sequences. FlashConv achieves a 2x speedup on the long-range arena benchmark and enables hybrid language models to generate text 2.4x faster than Transformers. Using FlashConv, the authors scale up hybrid H3-attention language models up to 2.7B parameters on the Pile dataset and achieve promising results. These models achieve lower perplexity than Transformers and outperform Transformers in zero- and few-shot learning on a majority of tasks in the SuperGLUE benchmark. Overall, this paper provides insights into the expressivity gap between SSMs and attention in language modeling and proposes solutions to improve their performance.

• - State space models (SSMs) underperform attention-based models like Transformers in language modeling tasks
• - SSMs are slower than Transformers due to inefficient hardware utilization
• - The authors propose a new SSM layer called H3 to address the limitations of existing SSMs, achieving comparable performance to attention on synthetic languages and coming close to Transformers on OpenWebText dataset
• - A hybrid model combining H3-attention outperforms Transformers on OpenWebText dataset by 1.0 perplexity per token (PPL)
• - FlashConv technique improves efficiency for training SSMs on modern hardware, achieving a 2x speedup on long-range arena benchmark and enabling faster text generation than Transformers
• - Hybrid H3-attention language models scaled up to 2.7B parameters achieve lower perplexity than Transformers and outperform them in zero- and few-shot learning on SuperGLUE benchmark

1. State space models (SSMs) are not as good as attention-based models like Transformers for understanding and using language. 2. SSMs are slower than Transformers because they don't use hardware efficiently. 3. The authors made a new layer called H3 to make SSMs better, and it works almost as well as Transformers on some languages and texts. 4. When H3 is combined with attention, it performs better than Transformers on a certain dataset by 1.0 perplexity per token (PPL). 5. A technique called FlashConv makes training SSMs faster on modern computers, so they can generate text more quickly than Transformers. Definitions- State space models (SSMs): A type of model used for understanding and using language. - Attention-based models: Models that pay more attention to important parts of the text when trying to understand it. - Transformers: A specific type of attention-based model that is very good at understanding language. - Hardware utilization: How well a computer uses its resources to do tasks efficiently. - Perplexity per token (PPL): A measure of how well a language model predicts the next word in a sentence. Lower PPL means better predictions. - FlashConv: A technique that helps make training state space models faster on modern computers."

Hungry Hungry Hippos: Towards Language Modeling with State Space Models

Language modeling is a key component of natural language processing (NLP) and has been traditionally dominated by attention-based models such as Transformers. While state space models (SSMs) have shown excellent sequence modeling performance in some domains, they underperform attention in language modeling tasks. Additionally, despite their linear scaling in sequence length, SSMs are slower than Transformers due to inefficient hardware utilization. To bridge the gap between SSMs and attention in language modeling, researchers from Google Brain recently proposed a new SSM layer called H3 and a novel training technique called FlashConv. This paper explores the performance of these techniques on synthetic languages and OpenWebText dataset as well as their scalability on long sequences using Pile dataset.

Background

Attention-based models like Transformer have become popular for NLP tasks due to their ability to capture long-range dependencies without increasing computation time or memory usage with longer sequences. However, they come with several drawbacks such as slow training speed and difficulty in capturing local context information efficiently. On the other hand, state space models (SSMs) can capture both local context information and long-range dependencies while being more efficient than Transformers when it comes to hardware utilization. Despite this advantage, existing SSMs struggle with two key challenges: recalling earlier tokens in the sequence and comparing tokens across the sequence which limits their performance compared to attention-based models on language modeling tasks.

H3 Layer

To address these limitations of existing SSMs for language modeling tasks, the authors propose a new SSM layer called H3 that is specifically designed for these capabilities. The H3 layer consists of three components: an encoder that maps input tokens into embeddings; an output decoder that maps embeddings back into output tokens; and a recurrent core that captures temporal dynamics within each token’s embedding over time steps t = 0...T−1 . The recurrent core uses multiple layers of gated convolutions to enable efficient comparison between different parts of the input sequence at each step t . Furthermore, it also utilizes skip connections from earlier time steps t − 1 , ... , 0 , allowing it to recall earlier parts of the input sequence effectively.

FlashConv Training Technique

To improve efficiency during training on modern hardware platforms such as GPUs or TPUs, the authors propose FlashConv - a fused block Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) algorithm - which enables 2x speedup on long range arena benchmark up to 8K length sequences while maintaining accuracy comparable to standard convolutional layers used by most existing neural networks today . It also introduces a novel state passing algorithm that leverages recurrent properties of SSMs enabling them scale up easily even for longer sequences beyond 8K length without sacrificing accuracy or speedup gains achieved through FFT acceleration .

Experimental Results

The authors conduct experiments using synthetic languages generated from character level RNNs trained on Penn Treebank corpus as well as OpenWebText dataset consisting real world text data collected from webpages crawled by Common Crawl project . They find that hybrid model combining 125M parameter H 3 -attention model with two additional attention layers outperforms Transformers by 1 PPL on OpenWebText dataset while achieving comparable results on synthetic languages . Furthermore , they scale up hybrid H 3 -attention language models up to 2 7B parameters using FlashConv technique achieving promising results lower perplexity than Transformers along with improved zero -and few shot learning performances across majority SuperGLUE benchmark tasks . Overall , this paper provides insights into expressivity gap between state space models (SS Ms )and attention based approaches in language modelling task s alongwith proposing solutions suchas H 3 layer and Flash Conv technique towards bridging this gap successfully . By leveraging advantages offeredby both approaches , hybrid approach achieves better results comparedto either one alone demonstrating potential applicationsin various NLP related fields going forward