Where intermediate-mass black holes could hide in the Galactic Centre: A
full parameter study with the S2 orbit
AI-generated keywords:
Intermediate-Mass Black Hole (IMBH)
- The Galactic Center (GC) of the Milky Way contains a massive black hole, SgrA*, and a compact nuclear star cluster with fast-moving young stars called S-stars
- Current star formation models cannot easily explain the presence and location of these stars, leading to the suggestion that an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) could be present in the GC
- Researchers used GRAVITY astrometric and SINFONI, KECK, and GNIRS spectroscopic data of S2 to investigate whether a second massive object could exist deep in the GC in the form of an IMBH binary companion to SgrA*
- They explored two types of settings: a hierarchical set-up where the star S2 orbits the SgrA*-IMBH binary and a non-hierarchical set-up where the IMBH trajectory lies outside the S2 orbit
- For the hierarchical case, IMBH masses greater than 2000 Msun on orbits with smaller semi-major axes than S2 were largely excluded. In contrast, for the non-hierarchical case, there were several pockets of valid IMBH solutions within the parameter space.
- However, further analysis revealed that IMBHs on semi-major axes larger than S2 tended to disrupt the resident star cluster in less than one million years.
- The current data did not formally require an IMBH's presence; if one existed in GC, it would have to be either a low mass IMBH inside the S2 orbit that moves on a short and significantly inclined trajectory or an IMBH with a semi major axis greater than 1".
- The researchers provided parameter maps of valid IMBH solutions in GC and discussed their general structure.
- They concluded that while an IMBH could potentially exist in GC, it would have to be on a specific trajectory to avoid disrupting its surrounding star cluster.
- The study highlights how important it is to understand dynamics when dealing with moving masses in GC as well as provides insights into potential future research directions.
Authors:
The GRAVITY Collaboration,
O. Straub,
M. Bauböck,
R. Abuter,
N. Aimar,
P. Amaro Seoane,
A. Amorim,
J. P. Berger,
H. Bonnet,
G. Bourdarot,
W. Brandner,
V. Cardoso,
Y. Clénet,
Y. Dallilar,
R. Davies,
P. T. de Zeeuw,
J. Dexter,
A. Drescher,
F. Eisenhauer,
N. M. Förster Schreiber,
A. Foschi,
P. Garcia,
F. Gao,
E. Gendron,
R. Genzel,
S. Gillessen,
M. Habibi,
X. Haubois,
G. Heißel,
T. Henning,
S. Hippler,
M. Horrobin,
L. Jochum,
L. Jocou,
A. Kaufer,
P. Kervella,
S. Lacour,
V. Lapeyrère,
J. -B. Le Bouquin,
P. Léna,
D. Lutz,
T. Ott,
T. Paumard,
K. Perraut,
G. Perrin,
O. Pfuhl,
S. Rabien,
D. C. Ribeiro,
M. Sadun Bordoni,
S. Scheithauer,
J. Shangguan,
T. Shimizu,
J. Stadler,
C. Straubmeier,
E. Sturm,
L. J. Tacconi,
F. Vincent,
S. von Fellenberg,
F. Widmann,
E. Wieprecht,
E. Wiezorrek,
J. Woillez,
S. Yazici
11 pages, 6 figures, accepted in A $\&$ A
Abstract: In the Milky Way the central massive black hole, SgrA*, coexists with a compact nuclear star cluster that contains a sub-parsec concentration of fast-moving young stars called S-stars. Their location and age are not easily explained by current star formation models, and in several scenarios the presence of an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) has been invoked. We use GRAVITY astrometric and SINFONI, KECK, and GNIRS spectroscopic data of S2 to investigate whether a second massive object could be present deep in the Galactic Centre (GC) in the form of an IMBH binary companion to SgrA*. To solve the three-body problem, we used a post-Newtonian framework and consider two types of settings: (i) a hierarchical set-up where the star S2 orbits the SgrA* - IMBH binary and (ii) a non-hierarchical set-up where the IMBH trajectory lies outside the S2 orbit. In both cases we explore the full 20-dimensional parameter space by employing a Bayesian dynamic nested sampling method. For the hierarchical case we find: IMBH masses > 2000 Msun on orbits with smaller semi-major axes than S2 are largely excluded. For the non-hierarchical case the parameter space contains several pockets of valid IMBH solutions. However, a closer analysis of their impact on the resident stars reveals that IMBHs on semi-major axes larger than S2 tend to disrupt the S-star cluster in less than a million years. This makes the existence of an IMBH among the S-stars highly unlikely. The current S2 data do not formally require the presence of an IMBH. If an IMBH hides in the GC, it has to be either a low-mass IMBH inside the S2 orbit that moves on a short and significantly inclined trajectory or an IMBH with a semi-major axis >1". We provide the parameter maps of valid IMBH solutions in the GC and discuss the general structure of our results. (abridged)
Submitted to arXiv on 07 Mar. 2023
- Comprehensive Summary
- Key points
- Layman's Summary
- Blog article
The Galactic Center (GC) of the Milky Way is home to a massive black hole, SgrA*, and a compact nuclear star cluster that contains a sub-parsec concentration of fast-moving young stars called S-stars. The presence and location of these stars cannot be easily explained by current star formation models, leading to the suggestion that an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) could be present in the GC. To investigate this possibility, researchers used GRAVITY astrometric and SINFONI, KECK, and GNIRS spectroscopic data of S2 to study whether a second massive object could exist deep in the GC in the form of an IMBH binary companion to SgrA*. They employed a post-Newtonian framework and considered two types of settings: (i) a hierarchical set-up where the star S2 orbits the SgrA*-IMBH binary and (ii) a non-hierarchical set-up where the IMBH trajectory lies outside the S2 orbit. The team explored the full 20-dimensional parameter space using Bayesian dynamic nested sampling methods for both cases. For the hierarchical case, they found that IMBH masses greater than 2000 Msun on orbits with smaller semi-major axes than S2 were largely excluded. In contrast, for the non-hierarchical case, there were several pockets of valid IMBH solutions within the parameter space. However, further analysis revealed that IMBHs on semi-major axes larger than S2 tended to disrupt the resident star cluster in less than one million years. This made it highly unlikely for an IMBH to exist among the S-stars. The current data did not formally require an IMBH's presence; if one existed in GC, it would have to be either a low mass IMBH inside the S2 orbit that moves on a short and significantly inclined trajectory or an IMBH with a semi major axis greater than 1". The researchers provided parameter maps of valid IMBH solutions in the GC and discussed their general structure. They concluded that while an IMBH could potentially exist in GC, it would have to be on a specific trajectory to avoid disrupting its surrounding star cluster. The study highlights how important it is to understand dynamics when dealing with moving masses in GC as well as provides insights into potential future research directions.
- - The Galactic Center (GC) of the Milky Way contains a massive black hole, SgrA*, and a compact nuclear star cluster with fast-moving young stars called S-stars
- - Current star formation models cannot easily explain the presence and location of these stars, leading to the suggestion that an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) could be present in the GC
- - Researchers used GRAVITY astrometric and SINFONI, KECK, and GNIRS spectroscopic data of S2 to investigate whether a second massive object could exist deep in the GC in the form of an IMBH binary companion to SgrA*
- - They explored two types of settings: a hierarchical set-up where the star S2 orbits the SgrA*-IMBH binary and a non-hierarchical set-up where the IMBH trajectory lies outside the S2 orbit
- - For the hierarchical case, IMBH masses greater than 2000 Msun on orbits with smaller semi-major axes than S2 were largely excluded. In contrast, for the non-hierarchical case, there were several pockets of valid IMBH solutions within the parameter space.
- - However, further analysis revealed that IMBHs on semi-major axes larger than S2 tended to disrupt the resident star cluster in less than one million years.
- - The current data did not formally require an IMBH's presence; if one existed in GC, it would have to be either a low mass IMBH inside the S2 orbit that moves on a short and significantly inclined trajectory or an IMBH with a semi major axis greater than 1".
- - The researchers provided parameter maps of valid IMBH solutions in GC and discussed their general structure.
- - They concluded that while an IMBH could potentially exist in GC, it would have to be on a specific trajectory to avoid disrupting its surrounding star cluster.
- - The study highlights how important it is to understand dynamics when dealing with moving masses in GC as well as provides insights into potential future research directions.
Scientists studied the center of our galaxy, where there is a big black hole and lots of young stars. They wanted to see if there might be another smaller black hole nearby. They looked at data from a star called S2 and found that if there was another black hole, it would have to be in a very specific place so it wouldn't mess up the other stars. They made maps showing where this other black hole could be. This study helps us understand how things move in space and gives ideas for more research.
Definitions- Galactic Center: The center of our Milky Way galaxy
- Black Hole: A place in space with extremely strong gravity that sucks everything in, even light
- Star Cluster: A group of stars that are close together
- Astrometric Data: Information about the position and movement of objects in space
- Spectroscopic Data: Information about the colors and brightnesses of light coming from objects in space
Exploring the Possibility of an Intermediate-Mass Black Hole in the Galactic Center
The Galactic Center (GC) of the Milky Way is home to a massive black hole, SgrA*, and a compact nuclear star cluster that contains a sub-parsec concentration of fast-moving young stars called S-stars. The presence and location of these stars cannot be easily explained by current star formation models, leading to the suggestion that an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) could be present in the GC. To investigate this possibility, researchers used GRAVITY astrometric and SINFONI, KECK, and GNIRS spectroscopic data of S2 to study whether a second massive object could exist deep in the GC in the form of an IMBH binary companion to SgrA*.
Investigating Two Possible Setups
The team employed a post-Newtonian framework and considered two types of settings: (i) a hierarchical set-up where the star S2 orbits the SgrA*-IMBH binary and (ii) a non-hierarchical set-up where the IMBH trajectory lies outside the S2 orbit. The team explored the full 20-dimensional parameter space using Bayesian dynamic nested sampling methods for both cases.
Results from Hierarchical Setup
For the hierarchical case, they found that IMBH masses greater than 2000 Msun on orbits with smaller semi-major axes than S2 were largely excluded. This means that if there was an IMBH it would have to be located on larger semi major axes than those occupied by other stars such as S2.
Results from Non Hierarchical Setup
In contrast, for non hierarchical setup there were several pockets of valid IMBH solutions within parameter space. However further analysis revealed that IMBHs on semi major axes larger than 1" tended to disrupt resident star cluster in less than one million years making it highly unlikely for an IMBH to exist among them .
Conclusion
The current data did not formally require an IMBH's presence; if one existed in GC it would have to be either low mass inside s2 orbit moving on short significantly inclined trajectory or with semi major axis greater than 1". Researchers provided parameter maps showing valid solutions for potential existence of such objects along with discussing general structure around them . They concluded while its possible for such objects exists but their trajectories must meet certain criteria so as not disrupt surrounding star clusters which makes it highly unlikely .
Implications h 3 >
This study highlights importance understanding dynamics when dealing with moving masses especially when dealing with dense regions like galactic center , also provides insights into potential future research directions .