Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2304.13758v1

In the study "Probing the Timescale of the 1.4 GHz Radio emissions as a Star formation tracer," authors R. C. Arango-Toro, L. Ciesla, O. Ilbert, B. Magnelli, E. F. Jiménez-Andrade, and V. Buat investigate the use of radio emissions as a tracer for star formation rate (SFR). Radio emissions have advantages over other SFR tracers since they are unaffected by dust and can be pinpointed at sub-arc-second levels; however, interpreting low frequency 1.4 GHz luminosity is challenging due to difficulties in modeling cosmic ray paths in the interstellar medium and their interactions with magnetic fields. The authors compare SFR derived from radio observations to those derived from spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling using Code Investigating GALaxy Emission (CIGALE) with a non-parametric star formation history model (SFH). They fit data over a wavelength range from ultraviolet (UV) up to mid-infrared (mid-IR) to better understand the behavior of radio emission as an SFR tracer and its link with star-formation histories. Their analysis reveals that approximately 27% of galaxies present a radio SFR at least ten times larger than the instantaneous SFR from SED-fitting, primarily affecting galaxies that show declining SFH activity over the last 300 million years. Both SFR indicators converge toward a consistent value when SFHs are averaged over periods longer than 150 million years to derive SED-based SFRs. While low-frequency 1.4 GHz radio is an excellent tracer for star formation activity in galaxies with constant or increasing SFHs, it is not reliable for quenching galaxies according to their results. The authors suggest that the sensitivity of low-frequency radio emission as an indicator of star formation time could be longer than 150 million years based on their analysis. They validate their results by checking for any remaining active galaxy nuclei (AGN) contribution and testing the impact of their SFH modeling approach on their findings.

• - Radio emissions can be used as a tracer for star formation rate (SFR)
• - Advantages of radio emissions over other SFR tracers include being unaffected by dust and pinpointing at sub-arc-second levels
• - Interpreting low frequency 1.4 GHz luminosity is challenging due to difficulties in modeling cosmic ray paths in the interstellar medium and their interactions with magnetic fields
• - The authors compare SFR derived from radio observations to those derived from spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling using Code Investigating GALaxy Emission (CIGALE) with a non-parametric star formation history model (SFH)
• - Approximately 27% of galaxies present a radio SFR at least ten times larger than the instantaneous SFR from SED-fitting, primarily affecting galaxies that show declining SFH activity over the last 300 million years
• - Both SFR indicators converge toward a consistent value when SFHs are averaged over periods longer than 150 million years to derive SED-based SFRs
• - Low-frequency 1.4 GHz radio is an excellent tracer for star formation activity in galaxies with constant or increasing SFHs, but not reliable for quenching galaxies according to their results
• - The sensitivity of low-frequency radio emission as an indicator of star formation time could be longer than 150 million years based on their analysis

Radio waves can help us find out how fast stars are forming. They are better than other methods because they aren't blocked by dust and can show us very small details. It's hard to understand some of the information we get from radio waves, but scientists use special tools to figure it out. Scientists compared two ways of using radio waves to measure star formation and found that sometimes one way gives a much bigger number than the other. Radio waves can tell us about star formation for a really long time, maybe even longer than 150 million years. Definitions- Radio emissions: energy that travels through space in the form of electromagnetic waves - Tracer: something used to follow or track a process or activity - Star formation rate (SFR): how quickly new stars are being formed in a galaxy - Luminosity: how bright something appears from Earth - Cosmic ray: high-energy particles that come from outside our solar system - Interstellar medium: the matter and radiation that exists between stars in a galaxy - Magnetic field: an invisible force created by magnets or moving electric charges - Spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling: a way of analyzing light emitted by objects like galaxies - Non-parametric star formation history model (SFH): a type of model used to estimate how quickly stars have formed over time - Instantaneous SFR: the rate at which new stars are forming right now - Quenching galaxies: galaxies where star formation has stopped or slowed down

Probing the Timescale of 1.4 GHz Radio Emissions as a Star Formation Tracer

In recent years, astronomers have been looking for ways to accurately trace star formation rates (SFR) in galaxies. In their study “Probing the Timescale of the 1.4 GHz Radio emissions as a Star formation tracer”, authors R. C. Arango-Toro, L. Ciesla, O. Ilbert, B. Magnelli, E. F. Jiménez-Andrade and V Buat investigate how low frequency 1.4 GHz radio emissions can be used as an SFR tracer and its link with star formation histories (SFH).

Advantages of Using Radio Emissions

Radio emissions have several advantages over other SFR tracers since they are unaffected by dust and can be pinpointed at sub-arcsecond levels with high accuracy; however, interpreting low frequency 1.4 GHz luminosity is challenging due to difficulties in modeling cosmic ray paths in the interstellar medium and their interactions with magnetic fields which affects the emission intensity from different regions within a galaxy..

Comparing SED Modeling With Non-Parametric SFHs

The authors compare SFR derived from radio observations to those derived from spectral energy distribution (SED) modeling using Code Investigating GALaxy Emission (CIGALE) with a non-parametric star formation history model (SFH). They fit data over a wavelength range from ultraviolet (UV) up to mid-infrared (mid-IR) to better understand the behavior of radio emission as an SFR tracer and its link with star formation histories..

Results Show Inconsistencies Between Low Frequency Radio And Instantaneous SFRs

Their analysis reveals that approximately 27% of galaxies present a radio SFR at least ten times larger than the instantaneous SFR from SED fitting primarily affecting galaxies that show declining SFH activity over the last 300 million years; however both indicators converge toward consistent values when SFHs are averaged over periods longer than 150 million years to derive more accurate estimates for instantaneous or average past star forming activities..

Low Frequency Radio Not Reliable For Quenching Galaxies

The authors suggest that while low frequency 1.4GHz radio is an excellent tracer for star formation activity in galaxies with constant or increasing SFHs it is not reliable for quenching galaxies according to their results; this could mean that sensitivity of low frequency radio emission as an indicator of star formation time could be longer than 150 million years based on their analysis..

Validation Of Results

The authors validate their results by checking for any remaining active galaxy nuclei contribution and testing the impact of their SFH modelling approach on their findings; they conclude that while there may still be some AGN contribution it does not affect overall trends seen between both indicators significantly enough to invalidate them..

Conclusion

Overall this research paper provides valuable insight into how we can use low frequency 1 . 4GHz radio emissions as an effective tool for tracing star formation rate in galaxies ; it shows us that while it works well for constant or increasing SFHS , it is less reliable when dealing with quenching galaxies due its sensitivity being potentially longer than 150 million years . The authors also provide evidence supporting these conclusions through validating checks such as AGN contributions tests etc .