Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2402.12572v1

Machine learning models are increasingly being utilized in various societal applications. However, concerns regarding legal and privacy issues often require that these models remain confidential. This has led to a growing skepticism about the fairness of these models among consumers who are impacted by their predictions. To address this issue, a system called FairProof has been proposed. <br> <br> FairProof utilizes Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs), a cryptographic primitive, to publicly verify the fairness of a model while still maintaining confidentiality. Additionally, a fairness certification algorithm tailored for fully-connected neural networks is introduced. This algorithm is compatible with ZKPs and implemented in the FairProof system using Gnark.<br> <br> In related work, previous research has focused on verifying fairness while preserving model confidentiality through third-party auditors or using cryptographic primitives to verify other properties of machine learning models. However, FairProof stands out by issuing fairness certificates by inspecting model weights post-training for neural networks without being tied to specific training pipelines.<br> <br> Furthermore, there is a classification of certification mechanisms for fairness into three categories: optimization programs, robustness-fairness connection leveraging mechanisms like adversarial training, and black-box query access learning theoretic approaches. FairProof specifically focuses on local Individual Fairness (IF) for neural networks using an iterative algorithm and demonstrates practical feasibility for small neural networks and tabular data.<br> <br> In conclusion, FairProof offers a protocol that enables model owners to issue publicly verifiable certificates while ensuring model uniformity and confidentiality. The experiments conducted showcase the practical feasibility of FairProof in enhancing transparency and trustworthiness in machine learning models used in societal applications. The use of ZKPs as a general-purpose tool holds promise beyond fairness considerations in machine learning systems.

• - Machine learning models are increasingly used in societal applications
• - Concerns about legal and privacy issues necessitate model confidentiality
• - Fairness skepticism among consumers impacted by model predictions
• - FairProof system introduced to address fairness concerns using Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs)
• - FairProof includes a fairness certification algorithm for fully-connected neural networks compatible with ZKPs and implemented using Gnark
• - FairProof issues fairness certificates by inspecting model weights post-training for neural networks without specific training pipelines
• - Classification of certification mechanisms for fairness into three categories: optimization programs, robustness-fairness connection leveraging mechanisms, and black-box query access learning theoretic approaches
• - FairProof focuses on local Individual Fairness (IF) for neural networks using an iterative algorithm, demonstrating practical feasibility for small neural networks and tabular data
• - Protocol enables model owners to issue publicly verifiable certificates while ensuring uniformity and confidentiality
• - Experiments show practical feasibility of FairProof in enhancing transparency and trustworthiness in machine learning models used in societal applications

Summary- Machine learning models are like smart tools used in everyday life. - People worry about keeping these tools safe and private. - Some people question if these tools treat everyone fairly. - A new system called FairProof helps make sure these tools are fair using a special way to prove it. - FairProof makes sure the smart tools work well for everyone and keeps things secret. Definitions- Machine learning models: Smart tools that can learn from data to make predictions or decisions. - Confidentiality: Keeping something private or secret. - Fairness: Treating everyone equally and justly. - Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs): A way to prove something is true without revealing any details about it. - Neural networks: Computer systems inspired by the human brain, used in machine learning.

Introduction

Machine learning models have become increasingly prevalent in various societal applications, from credit scoring to hiring decisions. However, concerns regarding legal and privacy issues often require that these models remain confidential. This has led to a growing skepticism about the fairness of these models among consumers who are impacted by their predictions. To address this issue, a system called FairProof has been proposed. FairProof utilizes Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs), a cryptographic primitive, to publicly verify the fairness of a model while still maintaining confidentiality. Additionally, it introduces a fairness certification algorithm tailored for fully-connected neural networks and implemented using Gnark.

The Need for Fairness in Machine Learning Models

As machine learning models continue to be integrated into various societal applications, there is an increasing need for transparency and accountability in their decision-making processes. The predictions made by these models can have significant impacts on individuals' lives, making it crucial to ensure that they are fair and unbiased. However, due to legal and privacy concerns, many organizations are hesitant to disclose the inner workings of their machine learning models. This lack of transparency can lead to mistrust among consumers who may question the fairness of these models.

FairProof: A Solution for Verifying Model Fairness

FairProof offers a solution that allows model owners to publicly verify the fairness of their model without compromising its confidentiality. It achieves this through the use of ZKPs – a cryptographic primitive that allows one party (the prover) to prove knowledge of certain information without revealing it to another party (the verifier). In the context of machine learning models, ZKPs can be used as evidence that the model was trained fairly without disclosing any sensitive information about its training data or parameters.

Fairness Certification Algorithm for Neural Networks

One unique aspect of FairProof is its introduction of a fairness certification algorithm specifically tailored for fully-connected neural networks. This algorithm is compatible with ZKPs and implemented using Gnark – a framework for building zk-SNARK circuits. The algorithm inspects the model weights post-training to ensure that the model is fair and unbiased. It does this by checking for any significant differences in weight values between different groups of individuals (e.g., based on race or gender). If such discrepancies are found, the model will not be certified as fair.

Comparison to Previous Research

Previous research has also focused on verifying fairness in machine learning models while preserving their confidentiality. However, these approaches often involve third-party auditors or rely on cryptographic primitives to verify other properties of the model. FairProof stands out by offering a solution that issues fairness certificates without being tied to specific training pipelines. This makes it more flexible and applicable to a wider range of machine learning models.

Certification Mechanisms for Fairness

There are three main categories of certification mechanisms for fairness: optimization programs, robustness-fairness connection leveraging mechanisms (e.g., adversarial training), and black-box query access learning theoretic approaches. FairProof falls under the category of optimization programs, as it uses an iterative algorithm to ensure local Individual Fairness (IF) in neural networks. This approach allows for more fine-grained control over the fairness of individual predictions rather than just overall group-level fairness.

Practical Feasibility

To demonstrate the practical feasibility of FairProof, experiments were conducted using small neural networks and tabular data. The results showed that FairProof was able to successfully certify fairness in these models while maintaining their confidentiality. This showcases how FairProof can enhance transparency and trustworthiness in machine learning models used in societal applications. By providing publicly verifiable certificates, consumers can have more confidence in the decisions made by these models, leading to increased trust and acceptance.

Future Applications of ZKPs in Machine Learning

While FairProof focuses on verifying fairness in machine learning models, the use of ZKPs holds promise for other applications as well. As a general-purpose tool, ZKPs can be utilized to verify various properties of machine learning models without compromising their confidentiality. This opens up possibilities for using ZKPs to address other concerns related to machine learning, such as privacy and security. Further research and development in this area could lead to even more innovative solutions for ensuring fairness and accountability in machine learning systems.

Conclusion

FairProof offers a protocol that enables model owners to issue publicly verifiable certificates while ensuring model uniformity and confidentiality. By utilizing Zero-Knowledge Proofs, it addresses the growing skepticism about the fairness of machine learning models among consumers impacted by their predictions. The introduction of a tailored fairness certification algorithm for neural networks further enhances the practical feasibility of FairProof. It also sets it apart from previous research by offering a flexible solution that is not tied to specific training pipelines. In conclusion, FairProof has the potential to enhance transparency and trustworthiness in societal applications that utilize machine learning models. Its use of ZKPs as a general-purpose tool holds promise beyond just addressing fairness concerns, making it an exciting development in the field of machine learning research.