Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2410.13509v1

, , , , In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various natural language processing tasks. However, they often struggle with producing accurate responses due to hallucinations. To address this issue, Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has been introduced as a solution to enhance LLMs by retrieving knowledge from external sources. The integration of RAG pipelines into LLMs has been achieved through instruction tuning, which optimizes LLMs to effectively utilize retrieved knowledge for diverse tasks. While supervised fine-tuning (SFT) has been the conventional approach for adapting LLMs to RAG pipelines, it tends to lead to overfitting and overlooks the varying data preferences among agents within the system. In response to these limitations, a new method called Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR) is proposed in this paper. DDR aims to train RAG systems end-to-end by aligning data preferences between different modules. By collecting rewards and optimizing each agent with a rollout method, DDR prompts agents to sample potential responses, evaluate their impact on the overall system, and optimize outputs that improve system performance. Experimental results on knowledge-intensive tasks demonstrate that DDR outperforms SFT, especially for smaller-scale LLMs that heavily rely on retrieved knowledge. Additionally, DDR exhibits a stronger capability in aligning data preferences between RAG modules, making the generation module more effective in extracting key information from documents and mitigating conflicts between parametric memory and external knowledge. Previous research has focused on optimizing LLMs for RAG through methods like INFO-RAG and RA-DIT. While reinforcement learning algorithms have been used for preference optimization in individual agents, DDR stands out by focusing on aligning data preferences across different agents within the multi-agent system. This approach avoids overfitting training signals and enhances the effectiveness of RAG optimization compared to traditional methods like SFT. Overall, the DDR method presents a promising advancement in training RAG systems and improving the performance of LLMs when handling complex language generation tasks. The code for implementing DDR is available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/RAG-DDR.

• - Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with accurate responses due to hallucinations
• - Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances LLMs by retrieving knowledge from external sources
• - Instruction tuning optimizes LLMs to effectively utilize retrieved knowledge for diverse tasks
• - Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR) aligns data preferences between different modules in RAG systems
• - DDR outperforms supervised fine-tuning (SFT), especially for smaller-scale LLMs heavily relying on retrieved knowledge
• - DDR improves the generation module's effectiveness in extracting key information and mitigating conflicts between parametric memory and external knowledge
• - DDR focuses on aligning data preferences across different agents within a multi-agent system, avoiding overfitting training signals and enhancing RAG optimization compared to traditional methods like SFT

Summary- Big talking robots sometimes make mistakes because they imagine things that are not true. - A special way called Retrieval-Augmented Generation helps these robots by getting information from outside sources. - Instruction tuning makes the robots better at using the information they find for different tasks. - Differentiable Data Rewards make sure that all parts of the robot work well together when using outside information. - Differentiable Data Rewards work better than supervised fine-tuning, especially for smaller robots that rely a lot on outside knowledge. Definitions- Large Language Models (LLMs): Big talking robots that use a lot of words to communicate and understand things. - Hallucinations: Seeing or imagining things that are not real. - Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG): A special way to help big talking robots by getting information from other places. - Optimization: Making something work as well as possible or improving its performance. - Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR): A method to make sure all parts of the robot work together well when using outside information. - Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT): Adjusting and improving the robot's performance based on specific instructions or guidance.

Introduction

Natural language processing (NLP) has seen significant advancements in recent years, with Large Language Models (LLMs) being at the forefront. These models have shown impressive capabilities in various NLP tasks such as text summarization, question-answering, and machine translation. However, they often struggle with producing accurate responses due to hallucinations – generating nonsensical or irrelevant information. To address this issue, Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has been introduced as a solution to enhance LLMs by retrieving knowledge from external sources. The integration of RAG pipelines into LLMs has been achieved through instruction tuning, which optimizes LLMs to effectively utilize retrieved knowledge for diverse tasks. While supervised fine-tuning (SFT) has been the conventional approach for adapting LLMs to RAG pipelines, it tends to lead to overfitting and overlooks the varying data preferences among agents within the system. In response to these limitations, a new method called Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR) is proposed in this research paper. DDR aims to train RAG systems end-to-end by aligning data preferences between different modules. By collecting rewards and optimizing each agent with a rollout method, DDR prompts agents to sample potential responses, evaluate their impact on the overall system, and optimize outputs that improve system performance.

Background: Retrieval-Augmented Generation

Retrieval-Augmented Generation involves integrating retrieval-based methods into language generation models like GPT-3 or BERT. This allows these models access to external knowledge sources such as databases or documents while generating responses for natural language queries. RAG systems typically consist of two main components: a retriever module and a generator module. The retriever module retrieves relevant information from external sources based on the input query/question using techniques like keyword matching or semantic search algorithms. The generator module then uses this retrieved information to generate a response.

The Need for Differentiable Data Rewards

While RAG has shown promising results in improving the performance of LLMs, there are still some limitations that need to be addressed. One major issue is the overreliance on supervised fine-tuning (SFT) for adapting LLMs to RAG pipelines. SFT involves training the model on a specific task by providing it with labeled data. However, this approach tends to lead to overfitting and does not account for varying data preferences among different agents within the system. For example, in a question-answering task, the retriever module may prefer longer answers while the generator module may perform better with shorter responses. This mismatch in data preferences can lead to conflicts and suboptimal performance of the overall system.

The DDR Method

To address these limitations, this research paper proposes a new method called Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR). DDR aims to train RAG systems end-to-end by aligning data preferences between different modules within the system. The key idea behind DDR is collecting rewards from each agent based on their contribution towards achieving the overall goal of generating accurate responses. These rewards are then used as training signals for optimizing each agent using a rollout method – sampling potential responses and evaluating their impact on system performance. By doing so, DDR prompts agents to learn how their actions affect other agents within the multi-agent system and optimize their outputs accordingly. This approach avoids overfitting training signals and enhances the effectiveness of RAG optimization compared to traditional methods like SFT.

Experimental Results

The researchers conducted experiments on knowledge-intensive tasks such as OpenBookQA and TriviaQA using two different LLM architectures: T5-base (small-scale) and T5-large (large-scale). The results showed that DDR outperforms SFT in both cases, especially for smaller-scale LLMs that heavily rely on retrieved knowledge. Additionally, DDR exhibited a stronger capability in aligning data preferences between RAG modules. This was evident in the improved performance of the generation module in extracting key information from documents and mitigating conflicts between parametric memory and external knowledge.

Related Work

Previous research has focused on optimizing LLMs for RAG through methods like INFO-RAG and RA-DIT. These approaches also use reinforcement learning algorithms to optimize individual agents within the system. However, DDR stands out by focusing on aligning data preferences across different agents within the multi-agent system.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this research paper presents a novel method called Differentiable Data Rewards (DDR) for training Retrieval-Augmented Generation systems end-to-end. By aligning data preferences between different modules within the system, DDR addresses limitations of traditional methods like supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Experimental results demonstrate that DDR outperforms SFT and exhibits a stronger capability in handling complex language generation tasks. The code for implementing DDR is available at https://github.com/OpenMatch/RAG-DDR.