Results of the summarizing process for the arXiv paper: 2410.23896v2

In the study titled "Exploring the Evolution of Red and Blue Galaxies in Different Cosmic Web Environments Using IllustrisTNG Simulation" by Biswajit Pandey and Anindita Nandi, the authors analyze the evolution of red and blue galaxies from redshift $z=3$ to $z=0$. They utilize Otsu's method to classify galaxies as red or blue at each redshift and determine their geometric environments based on the eigenvalues of the deformation tensor. The analysis reveals an interesting trend where initially, blue galaxies are more prevalent in clusters compared to filaments, sheets, and voids. However, this pattern shifts at lower redshifts, with red fractions increasing earlier in denser environments. At redshifts below $z<1$, it is observed that most massive galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})>10.5$) are quenched across all environments. On the other hand, low-mass galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})<10.5$) show a stronger influence from their surroundings, with clusters hosting higher proportions of red galaxies at lower redshifts. Furthermore, the study highlights a slower mass growth for low-mass galaxies in clusters at $z<1$. Filaments exhibit relative red fractions comparable to clusters for low masses but interestingly harbor nearly 60% of low-mass blue galaxies, indicating a diverse galaxy population experiencing a broader range of evolutionary stages due to less intense environmental quenching. Clusters, despite being the densest environment, display the highest relative blue fraction for high-mass galaxies at lower redshifts. This phenomenon is attributed to interactions or mergers that can temporarily reignite star formation in some high-mass galaxies within clusters. The $(u-r)$ color distribution transitions from unimodal to bimodal by $z=2$ across all environments. Notably, at $z<1$, clusters exhibit the highest median color and lowest median specific star formation rate (sSFR), with stellar mass emerging as the primary driver of color evolution in massive galaxies. Overall, this comprehensive analysis suggests that while stellar mass predominantly governs quenching in high-mass galaxies, a complex interplay between mass and environment shapes the evolutionary trajectory of low-mass galaxies. The findings shed light on how different cosmic web environments impact galaxy evolution over cosmic time scales.

• - Study title: "Exploring the Evolution of Red and Blue Galaxies in Different Cosmic Web Environments Using IllustrisTNG Simulation" by Biswajit Pandey and Anindita Nandi
• - Analysis spans redshift $z=3$ to $z=0
• - Otsu's method used for galaxy classification as red or blue at each redshift
• - Geometric environments determined based on eigenvalues of deformation tensor
• - Initially, blue galaxies more prevalent in clusters compared to filaments, sheets, and voids; shifts at lower redshifts with red fractions increasing earlier in denser environments
• - Most massive galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})>10.5$) quenched across all environments at $z<1$
• - Low-mass galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})<10.5$ show stronger influence from surroundings, clusters host higher proportions of red galaxies at lower redshifts
• - Slower mass growth for low-mass galaxies in clusters at $z<1
• - Filaments exhibit relative red fractions comparable to clusters for low masses but harbor nearly 60% of low-mass blue galaxies, indicating diverse galaxy population experiencing broader range of evolutionary stages due to less intense environmental quenching
• - Clusters display highest relative blue fraction for high-mass galaxies at lower redshifts attributed to interactions or mergers reigniting star formation temporarily
• - $(u-r)$ color distribution transitions from unimodal to bimodal by $z=2$ across all environments; clusters exhibit highest median color and lowest median specific star formation rate (sSFR) at $z<1$
• - Stellar mass primary driver of color evolution in massive galaxies; complex interplay between mass and environment shapes evolutionary trajectory of low-mass galaxies

Summary1. Scientists studied how red and blue galaxies change in different space areas using a computer simulation. 2. They looked at galaxies from a long time ago until now. 3. A special method called Otsu's method was used to decide if a galaxy is red or blue. 4. Different shapes of space were found by looking at how things stretch in different ways. 5. Big galaxies stop growing in all places early, while small ones change more depending on where they are. Definitions- Redshift: A way to measure how far away something in space is moving. - Galaxy: A huge group of stars, planets, and other things in space held together by gravity. - Simulation: Pretending something is happening on a computer to learn about it without doing it for real. - Method: A specific way of doing something to get an answer or solve a problem. - Environment: The surroundings or conditions that affect how something grows or changes.

Introduction

The study titled "Exploring the Evolution of Red and Blue Galaxies in Different Cosmic Web Environments Using IllustrisTNG Simulation" by Biswajit Pandey and Anindita Nandi delves into the evolution of red and blue galaxies from redshift $z=3$ to $z=0$. The authors utilize Otsu's method to classify galaxies as red or blue at each redshift and determine their geometric environments based on the eigenvalues of the deformation tensor. This research paper provides a comprehensive analysis of how different cosmic web environments impact galaxy evolution over cosmic time scales.

Background

The concept of cosmic web refers to the large-scale structure of matter in the universe, consisting of filaments, sheets, clusters, and voids. These structures are formed due to gravitational collapse, resulting in dense regions where galaxies are more likely to form. Understanding how these different environments influence galaxy evolution is crucial for gaining insights into the formation and growth mechanisms of galaxies. Previous studies have shown that environment plays a significant role in shaping galaxy properties such as color, morphology, star formation rate (SFR), and stellar mass. In particular, it has been observed that galaxies residing in denser environments tend to have redder colors and lower SFR compared to those in less dense regions. This phenomenon is known as environmental quenching – where external factors such as interactions with neighboring galaxies or gas stripping can suppress star formation in a galaxy. However, there is still much debate about how exactly environment affects galaxy evolution. Some studies suggest that stellar mass is the primary driver for quenching in high-mass galaxies while others propose a complex interplay between mass and environment for low-mass galaxies.

Data Analysis

To investigate this further, Pandey and Nandi utilized data from IllustrisTNG simulation – a state-of-the-art cosmological simulation that models the formation and evolution of galaxies in a large volume of the universe. The simulation provides a realistic representation of the cosmic web, allowing for a detailed analysis of how different environments impact galaxy properties. The authors used Otsu's method to classify galaxies as red or blue at each redshift based on their $(u-r)$ color distribution. This technique separates the two populations by finding an optimal threshold value that minimizes the intra-class variance. They then determined the geometric environment of each galaxy using eigenvalues from the deformation tensor – a measure of how much a structure has been stretched or compressed due to gravitational forces.

Evolutionary Trends

The analysis revealed an interesting trend where initially, blue galaxies are more prevalent in clusters compared to filaments, sheets, and voids. However, this pattern shifts at lower redshifts, with red fractions increasing earlier in denser environments. At redshifts below $z<1$, it is observed that most massive galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})>10.5$) are quenched across all environments. On the other hand, low-mass galaxies ($\log(\frac{M_{*}}{M_{\odot}})<10.5$) show a stronger influence from their surroundings, with clusters hosting higher proportions of red galaxies at lower redshifts. Furthermore, filaments exhibit relative red fractions comparable to clusters for low masses but interestingly harbor nearly 60% of low-mass blue galaxies. This suggests that filaments host a diverse population of galaxies experiencing a broader range of evolutionary stages due to less intense environmental quenching compared to clusters.

Impact on Mass Growth

Another significant finding from this study is that there is slower mass growth for low-mass galaxies in clusters at $z<1$. This could be due to the intense environmental effects in clusters, such as ram pressure stripping and tidal interactions, which can hinder gas accretion and star formation in low-mass galaxies.

Color Distribution

The $(u-r)$ color distribution transitions from unimodal to bimodal by $z=2$ across all environments. Notably, at $z<1$, clusters exhibit the highest median color and lowest median specific star formation rate (sSFR), with stellar mass emerging as the primary driver of color evolution in massive galaxies. This further supports the idea that environment plays a more significant role in shaping galaxy properties for low-mass galaxies compared to high-mass ones.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Pandey and Nandi's study provides valuable insights into how different cosmic web environments impact galaxy evolution over cosmic time scales. The analysis reveals a complex interplay between mass and environment, where stellar mass predominantly governs quenching in high-mass galaxies while a diverse range of factors influences low-mass galaxies. This research has important implications for our understanding of galaxy formation and growth mechanisms. It also highlights the need for further studies to explore the specific processes responsible for environmental quenching in different regions of the cosmic web. Overall, this study contributes significantly to our knowledge of how galaxies evolve within their respective environments and sheds light on the intricate relationship between mass and environment in shaping galaxy properties.