Revisiting mesoscopic traffic flow simulation in SUMO: Limitations, analysis, and an alternative

Abstract: Mesoscopic traffic flow models combines the merits of both macroscopic and microscopic models by capturing individual vehicle behavior in great detail and remaining the computational efficiency. At the time of this study, the mesoscopic model proposed by Eissfeldt (2004) is used in Simulation of Urban MObility (SUMO). The movement of vehicles is governed by dynamic headways between edges. However, the model does not fully comply with the principle of the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model. Several problems are identified, including the incomplete consideration of queue dynamics and the limited implementation of backward traveling spaces. Two case study scenarios demonstrate that the problems lead to unrealistic onset and recovery pattern of congestion. The magnitude of congestion is generally underestimated with this model. To address these drawbacks, a proper mesoscopic discrete-time implementation of link transmission model, which follows the LWR principle, is proposed. By explicitly incorporating backward traveling spaces to capture queue spillback phenomena, the proposed model provides a more precise representation of congestion dynamics. The link density outputs are consistent with the kinematic wave theory and the microscopic traffic simulation in SUMO, thus verifying its theoretical accuracy.